2026-11-09
A gearbox designer reviews a failed Bevel Gear set from a steel mill drive. The gear teeth show pitting and scuffing, and the lubricant has oxidized into a dark sludge. The operating temperature log shows that the oil sump reached 110 degrees Celsius during the summer production peak, while the design assumption was 80 degrees Celsius. The material was a standard case-carburized steel, and the lubricant was an ISO VG 220 mineral oil. Both were adequate at 80 degrees Celsius but not at 110 degrees Celsius. The failure was not a manufacturing defect. It was a temperature-related selection error. This guide explains how operating temperature drives the choice of material and lubricant for bevel gears.
The operating temperature of a Bevel Gear set is determined by the heat generated at the tooth contact and by the heat removed by the housing, the lubricant, and the cooling system. The heat generation depends on the load, the sliding velocity, and the friction coefficient. The heat removal depends on the housing surface area, the ambient temperature, and the lubricant flow. When the operating temperature rises, three things happen. First, the lubricant viscosity drops, and the oil film thickness decreases. Second, the material strength drops, and the allowable contact stress decreases. Third, the lubricant oxidizes faster, and the additive package depletes. The material and the lubricant must be selected so that the gear can carry the load at the actual operating temperature, not at the catalog reference temperature. In our factory, we manufacture Bevel Gear sets for industrial drives and we request the operating temperature range with every enquiry. Saifu has been manufacturing bevel gears for over 15 years.
The operating temperature is not a single number. It varies along the tooth flank, along the pitch line, and over the duty cycle. The designer must consider the bulk oil temperature, the tooth flank temperature, and the peak temperature at the start of a heavy load cycle. The material and the lubricant must be selected for the highest sustained temperature, not for the average.
The material selection for a Bevel Gear depends on the operating temperature and on the stress level. At temperatures up to 120 degrees Celsius, standard case-carburizing steels such as 20MnCr5 or 18CrNiMo7-6 are suitable. They provide a hard case of 58 to 62 HRC and a tough core of 30 to 40 HRC. At temperatures between 120 and 180 degrees Celsius, the material must resist tempering and oxidation. Nitriding steels such as 31CrMoV9 or 34CrAlNi7 are used because they maintain their hardness at higher temperatures. At temperatures above 180 degrees Celsius, special alloys or surface treatments are required, and the lubricant becomes the limiting factor. The table below shows the material options and their temperature limits.
| Material grade | Heat treatment | Surface hardness | Maximum continuous temperature | Typical application |
| 20MnCr5 | Case carburizing | 58 – 62 HRC | 120°C | General industrial drives |
| 18CrNiMo7-6 | Case carburizing | 58 – 62 HRC | 140°C | Heavy duty gearboxes |
| 31CrMoV9 | Nitriding | 650 – 750 HV | 180°C | High temperature drives |
| 34CrAlNi7 | Nitriding | 700 – 800 HV | 200°C | Steel mill and kiln drives |
In our factory, we verify the material grade and the heat treatment for each Bevel Gear order. We also request the operating temperature range so that we can recommend the correct grade. Saifu Vietnam Company Limited provides the material certificate and the hardness test report with each shipment.
The lubricant viscosity is the most temperature-sensitive property. A typical ISO VG 220 mineral oil has a viscosity of 220 centistokes at 40 degrees Celsius and about 20 centistokes at 100 degrees Celsius. The viscosity index describes how much the viscosity changes with temperature. A high viscosity index oil changes less, and it maintains a thicker oil film at high temperature. The oil film thickness determines whether the gear operates in the full-film regime or in the boundary regime. In the full-film regime, the metal surfaces are separated by the oil film, and the wear is very low. In the boundary regime, the asperities touch, and the wear rate increases rapidly. The table below shows the viscosity and the film regime at different temperatures for three lubricant types.
| Lubricant type | Viscosity at 40°C | Viscosity at 100°C | Viscosity index | Film regime at 100°C |
| Mineral oil ISO VG 220 | 220 cSt | 20 cSt | 95 | Boundary (marginal) |
| Mineral oil ISO VG 320 | 320 cSt | 26 cSt | 95 | Mixed (acceptable) |
| Synthetic PAO ISO VG 220 | 220 cSt | 28 cSt | 140 | Full film (good) |
| Synthetic PAG ISO VG 220 | 220 cSt | 32 cSt | 170 | Full film (excellent) |
Gear design engineer's note: The lubricant selection must be based on the viscosity at the operating temperature, not at 40 degrees Celsius. A mineral oil that is adequate at 80 degrees Celsius may be marginal at 100 degrees Celsius. A synthetic oil with a high viscosity index maintains a thicker film at high temperature and is preferred for high-temperature bevel gear applications. In our factory, we recommend the lubricant viscosity based on the operating temperature and the pitch line velocity. Saifu provides a lubricant selection chart with each bevel gear order.
For high-temperature operation, the lubricant must resist oxidation and maintain its viscosity. A synthetic PAO or PAG oil with a high viscosity index and an oxidation inhibitor package is recommended. The oil flow must be sufficient to remove the heat, and an oil cooler may be required. For low-temperature operation, the lubricant must remain fluid and pumpable. A synthetic oil with a low pour point is recommended, and the oil sump may need a heater to bring the oil to a pumpable viscosity before startup. In both cases, the lubricant must be compatible with the seal material and with the gear material. In our factory, we test the lubricant compatibility with the seal and the gear material before recommending a product. We also recommend an oil analysis program to monitor the viscosity, the oxidation, and the water content during service.
The lubrication strategy also includes the method of application. Splash lubrication is suitable for low-speed and moderate-temperature gears. Forced circulation is required for high-speed or high-temperature gears because the oil must remove the heat as well as lubricate the teeth. Oil mist lubrication is used for high-speed gears where the oil flow must be precise and the heat generation is moderate.
The specification should include five items. The first is the operating temperature range, including the bulk oil temperature and the peak tooth flank temperature. The second is the material grade and the heat treatment. The third is the lubricant type, the viscosity grade, and the viscosity index. The fourth is the lubrication method, splash, forced, or mist. The fifth is the oil analysis interval. The verification should include three checks. The first is the material certificate and hardness test. The second is the lubricant viscosity measurement at the operating temperature. The third is the oil analysis after the first 500 hours of operation. In our factory, we perform the material and hardness checks on every lot and provide the report with the shipment. We also offer a thermal analysis of the gearbox to predict the operating temperature before the gear is manufactured. Saifu Vietnam Company Limited provides the thermal analysis report with the quotation for high-temperature applications.
We recommend that the designer verify the lubricant viscosity at the operating temperature, not just the ISO grade. Two oils with the same ISO grade can have very different viscosities at 100 degrees Celsius if their viscosity indexes are different. The high viscosity index oil is the better choice for high-temperature bevel gear applications.
The operating temperature of a Bevel Gear is the decisive variable for material and lubricant selection. The material must resist softening and oxidation at the maximum continuous temperature. The lubricant must maintain a sufficient viscosity and film thickness at the operating temperature. The material grades range from case-carburized steel for temperatures up to 140 degrees Celsius to nitriding steel for temperatures up to 200 degrees Celsius. The lubricant selection depends on the viscosity at the operating temperature and on the viscosity index. The lubrication method must remove the heat as well as lubricate the teeth. The specification should include the temperature range, the material grade, the lubricant type and viscosity, the lubrication method, and the oil analysis interval. Saifu Vietnam Company Limited has been manufacturing Bevel Gear sets for over 15 years and provides full thermal and lubrication selection support for our customers.